Departments
Veterans for Peace President Mike Ferner responds to President Obama's rebranded occupation of Iraq
by Mike Ferner
August 31, 2010
A veteran’s perspective makes it clear that two major points must be made in response to President Obama’s announcement regarding combat troops leaving Iraq.
First, there is no such thing as “non combat troops.” It is a contradiction in terms. It is internally inconsistent. It is illogical. It is simply not true.
Ask any of the millions of men and women who went through basic training and they can tell you that every U.S. troop anywhere in the world was indoctrinated and trained in the basics of combat. While in Iraq, the transition from mechanics or communications back to combat-ready soldier takes but an order. “Non-combat troops” is simply the latest in a long line of military euphemisms meant to obscure painful reality.
The second point can best be made by drafting a section of the President’s remarks for him. If Veterans For Peace were to do that it would read something like this.
-------
“And now, fellow Americans, let us begin a new era of candor and honesty about the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. Specifically, I’m referring to the true costs of war – something that must be considered if we are to judge if continued war is worth it.
You have seen that the cost to taxpayers of these wars has exceeded one trillion dollars, nearly all of which has been considered ‘off budget,’ appropriated by extraordinary or ‘supplemental’ spending bills. It may be hard to believe, but large though that figure may be, it is only the smaller portion of what we will spend in total.
We are already investing unprecedented amounts in Veterans Administration staff and facilities to try and cope with the millions of men and women who have cycled through a war zone deployment – and of course many have been through multiple deployments.
Our experience thus far tells us to expect literally hundreds of thousands of cases of PTSD and Traumatic Brain Injuries – injuries that are often difficult to diagnose at first and difficult to treat. These are, of course, in addition to the many thousands of visibly wounded who, at great expense, must go through rehabilitation and a lifetime of support in order to function to their fullest. Thousands more will require years, perhaps decades, of long-term care because their injuries have left them so broken they require round-the-clock attention.
But since we are initiating an era of candor, we go farther – and by that I mean the cost to families, communities and society as a whole. Volumes have literally been written on this point, but let me leave you with a brief example you can easily expand for yourself.
We have already heard of the abnormally high rate of suicides among returning veterans. The real number is undoubtedly higher since some will always remain a mystery. We’ve heard also of a growing tide of domestic violence that leaves families broken and terrorized.
Beyond the draining medical, psychological and emotional costs to the individuals directly involved, imagine the cost to the communities where this occurs: whole battalions of police, fire, EMT, courts, probation officers, social workers and sadly, prison guards will be needed to deal with the true costs of war. It is uncomfortable to admit, but this is indeed one area of the economy I can guarantee will grow significantly.
Then there is an exponentially greater cost borne by the people of Iraq and Afghanistan – greater in every way: emotionally, economically, in human suffering, in destroyed opportunities, in shattered lives and minds, in hearts that will remain forever broken. We can do precious little to repair much of that kind of damage. But I can tell you this, my fellow Americans, we must at least pay the bill to rebuild the roads, water and sewer plants, hospitals, schools and residences we have destroyed.
It is not pleasant to describe such things and indeed, these costs will continue to weigh heavily on our nation well into our grandchildren’s generation. But we cannot pretend otherwise.”
This is the message that should come from the White House tonight if truth were indeed the coin of the realm. We won’t hear it, but that will make it no less true.
####
Ferner is also author of Inside the Red Zone: A Veteran For Peace Reports from Iraq,”(Praeger/Greenwood, 2006)
|
 |
Recent War Articles
Believe in violence and be saved December 24, 2010 Robert C. Koehler
Be the peace you want to see on Earth December 24, 2010 David Swanson
Whitewashing defeat: Obama's indecisiveness defines his presidency December 22, 2010 Ramzy Baroud
Pearl Harbor: A successful war lie December 8, 2010 David Swanson
A hollow bomber jacket December 6, 2010 Norman Solomon
WikiLeaks: Demystifying “Diplomacy” November 29, 2010 Norman Solomon
"Die for a Tie" -- How the Korean War began November 26, 2010 David Swanson
U.S. wars are bankrupting the world November 20, 2010 David Swanson
Peddling war to children November 18, 2010 Robert C. Koehler
Open letter to Congress on Veteran's Day 2010 November 11, 2010 United for Peace and Justice Afghanistan Working Group
One place to cut spending: Kidnapping and torture November 8, 2010 David Swanson
Deaths revealed by Wikileaks are tip of an iceberg October 24, 2010 Nicolas Davies
Creating a new courage October 24, 2010 Jerica Arents
Then they came for me October 18, 2010 Robert C. Koehler
Poll: Most Americans Don't Want War with Iran October 13, 2010 Monique Coppola, Public News Service - VA
The criminality of nuclear deterrence today: International law as anchoring ground October 7, 2010 Professor Francis A. Boyle
The Nazi virus October 7, 2010 Robert C. Koehler
Farewell to arms: Jenny, Iraq and the next war October 6, 2010 Ramzy Baroud
Drone warfare on trial October 2, 2010 Robert C. Koehler
Petrodollar warfare: Dollars, euros and the upcoming Iranian oil bourse October 2, 2010 by William R. Clark (Friday August 05 2005)
The book the Pentagon burned October 2, 2010 David Swanson
U.S. Vietnam Veteran returns to his war October 2, 2010 Richard S. Ehrlich
Obama-Men: Innocents Abroad; Politicos at Home October 1, 2010 Ray McGovern
Inspector General criticism doesn't faze FBI raids on midwestern anti-war activists September 26, 2010 Coleen Rowley, War Is A Crime.org
The war is lost: Another perspective on the Afghanistan war September 23, 2010 Frank Brodhead
Holy war September 19, 2010 Robert C. Koehler
The indefensible drones: A ground zero reflection September 11, 2010 Kathy Kelly, WarIsACrime.org
Implications of a pointless war September 10, 2010 Robert C. Koehler
A speech for endless war September 2, 2010 Norman Solomon
Let's fact check the AP's fact checking on Obama's speech September 2, 2010 David Swanson
Veterans for Peace President Mike Ferner responds to President Obama's rebranded occupation of Iraq August 31, 2010 Mike Ferner
Peace movement pushes for end to war on Iraq August 30, 2010 David Swanson
Blackwater vs. Pinkwater: The wife of Erik Prince picks a fight with CODEPINK August 25, 2010 Medea Benjamin
Last of the combat troops leaving Iraq? – Only in your dreams August 21, 2010 Bill Noxid
Gen. Petraeus goes to media war August 16, 2010 Norman Solomon
The next war August 5, 2010 Robert C. Koehler
State of denial: After the big Leak, spinning for war July 27, 2010 Norman Solomon
The crematorium of empires July 18, 2010 David Swanson, War Is A Crime.org
The war drones on July 8, 2010 Robert C. Koehler
The peace movement's progress July 5, 2010 David Swanson
Unanimous conformity in the Senate July 1, 2010 Norman Solomon
Senator Carl Levin Fiddling With War While Detroit Burns June 30, 2010 Medea Benjamin, WarIsACrime.org
Obama Misses the Afghan Exit Ramp June 25, 2010 Ray McGovern
From great man to great screwup: Behind the McChrystal uproar June 24, 2010 Norman Solomon
Obama and Insubordination: Is He Truman or Mr. Milquetoast? June 24, 2010 Ray McGovern
The wonders of the American way of war June 1, 2010 David Swanson
The one thing we can agree on is peace May 27, 2010 David Swanson
Stopping Orwell's nightmare May 27, 2010 Robert C. Koehler
Fear, war, greed, disaster, and journalism May 25, 2010 David Swanson, WarIsACrime.org
The learning curve of peace May 21, 2010 Robert C. Koehler
Karazai’s Washington visit: the war awaiting Kandahar May 20, 2010 Ramzy Baroud
McChrystal: Beheadings of our allies simply to be expected May 16, 2010 David Swanson
Obama scraps Iraq withdrawal May 13, 2010 David Swanson
Dear Fiscal Conservative War Supporter May 5, 2010 David Swanson
Ending wars: The Flexible waiverable timetable approach April 21, 2010 David Swanson
I won't vote for you if you vote to escalate war April 21, 2010 David Swanson
You say you want a revolution... April 2, 2010 Tom Over
Globalization and the US wars in Afghanistan and Iraq March 31, 2010 Tom Over
The world still can't wait, says activist against US wars in Afghanistan and Iraq March 30, 2010 Tom Over
Reflections on an anniversary March 26, 2010 Robert C. Koehler
Antiwar activity sees surge for 7th anniversary of Iraq War invasion March 20, 2010 PJEP
Rachel Corrie: Justice delayed is justice denied March 16, 2010 Mahmoud El-Yousseph
War in a box March 11, 2010 Norman Solomon
Cost of war is budgetary "Elephant in the Room" March 4, 2010 John Marty, State Senator and DFL Candidate for Governor of Minnesota
War politics: numb and number February 27, 2010 Norman Solomon
Blocking war funding just got easier February 2, 2010 David Swanson
Don't call it a February 2, 2010 Norman Solomon
Read War Articles by Year: 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000 |